National Association of Recording Arts and Sciences
(Grammy)

Best New Artist (1976) with Starland Vocal Band
Best Arrangement for Voices (1976) with Starland Vocal Band
Record of the Year (Nomination)

Washingon Area Music Association
(Wammie)

2010

Musician of the Year
Pop/Rock Instrumentalist

2009

Pop/Rock Instrumentalist

2008

Musician of the Year
WAMA/SAW Songwriter of the Year
Pop Rock Recording
    (Jon Carroll & Love Returns - Live Returns Live at the Barns)
Pop/Rock Vocalist
Pop/Rock Duo/Group (Jon Carroll & Love Returns)
Pop/Rock Instrumentalist
Record Label of the Year (Azalea City Recordings)

2007

Song of the Year (Paint That Dollar)
Album of the Year (Love Returns)
Musician of the Year (General Award Category)
Rock Male Vocalist
Rock Recording (Love Returns)
WAMA/SAW Songwriter of the Year
Rock Instrumentalist
Record Label of the Year (Azalea City Recordings)

Pop/Rock Best Instrumentalist (2006)
Musician of the Year (1995)
Pop/Rock Vocalist of the Year (1994)
Musician of the Year (1992)
Vocalist of the Year (1988)
Songwriter of the Year (1982)